Compared to other works I've seen so far, this one is less in the realm of magical and suspense, equipped with much fewer whimsical and enchanting moments in the traditional sense...there is clear imbalance among these protagonists, with Ida being the one with (significantly) least screen time, but Rivette likely doesn't care. The eventual encounter of the other 2, Louise and Ninon, and the bonding thereafter, is clearly reminiscent of Celine and Julie Go Boating, and that includes their joint effort in subverting gender dynamics...see full review at https://letterboxd.com/ziggyzaggy/film/up-down-fragile/
讨论的议题似乎是这几年看的电影中最深刻、沉重的感觉这类电影越来越少地进入主流视野两个小时的片长但因为事件时间线的整体跨度太大让我觉得很割裂对人物的塑造也有所欠缺给我的感觉就是本来是以母亲的视角去讲述这个故事但呈现出来的却更多地偏向律师铁道游击队之战后篇虽然不可否认确实律师才是整个事件的中流砥柱母亲对儿子的情感在最后三分之一的时候爆发但仍显得很平 致敬所有一直为Human Rights斗争的律师 [Festival des Deutschen Films 2023] [6.5/10]